What if Green Day sucked

[Guest]

pssh. except billie joe still looks like a thirteen year old. with wrinkles.

And grey hair! At least we know he can grow a beard

Although you wouldn't say so when looking at the height of certain members

They are a bit dinky, bless them

[unabrasiveadhesive]

Dude, there's a difference between layering a studio track and autotuning the fuck out of something.

sarcasm detection fail.

but anyways its the same idea , to make someone sound better than he/she actually is.

[Katarina.]

Why would anyone go to their concert if they didn't just suck, but also lip synced? It'd be like a song like Longview that's playing, and when Billie's all "Hey! Hey! Hey!" you can hear the song continue with "I sit around and watch the phone" and then Billie would be like "Hey! Uhm.. oh, fuck." Ahaha

Well, if they sucked there wouldn't even be a Dookie album. Nevermind.

[ifmemoryserves]

sarcasm detection fail.

but anyways its the same idea , to make someone sound better than he/she actually is.

That was awful sarcasm....

And yes, like I said, they're not going to leave completely raw vocal tracks on record. They want it to sound perfect or as close to it as they can get. Sure that doesn't mean they should use autotune or whatever, but they can't still fix it up a little without jeopardizing the true vocal ability.

[badwolf]

What if? There are no what if's. Green Day do suck.

[Daughter.of.Rage.and.Love]

Well, if they sucked there wouldn't even be a Dookie album. Nevermind.

Or it would sound awful.

Never mind, I don't even want to think about that. seriously...trying to imagine how that would sound all autotuned. It's horrible!

[Guest]

sarcasm detection fail.

but anyways its the same idea , to make someone sound better than he/she actually is.

I'm sorry I think we'd all just written you off as a noob

[Nele]

sarcasm detection fail.

but anyways its the same idea , to make someone sound better than he/she actually is.

It's not the same idea, since Billie Joe's able to sing the note. They are a big band now and have more money to polish things up, nothing wrong with that.

[unabrasiveadhesive]

What if? There are no what if's. Green Day do suck.

OMFG we have a non-believer here everybody

[Daughter.of.Rage.and.Love]

What if? There are no what if's. Green Day do suck.

:o :o :o

[Guest]

Or it would sound awful.

Never mind, I don't even want to think about that. seriously...trying to imagine how that would sound all autotuned. It's horrible!

They'd have a matching horrific video, they'd be sat in a supercar with some sluts, showing how pimp they are.

[Katarina.]

Never mind, I don't even want to think about that. seriously...trying to imagine how that would sound all autotuned. It's horrible!

Me neither Oh no, now I'm trying to imagine how songs like 2000 Light Years Away, Christie Road, GTP, 80 and song like that would sound autotuned.

[Daughter.of.Rage.and.Love]

They'd have a matching horrific video, they'd be sat in a supercar with some sluts, showing how pimp they are.

Video to Sassafras Roots. What you just described, but then driving in circles around a house.

bad humour, sorry

And I still don't know how to write Sassafras(s)... one or two S's in the end?

[Marlee]

if we know that they don't, why is there still discussion? lol

[CaesarSalad]

What if? There are no what if's. Green Day do suck.

you--me--outside.

NOW.

[ifmemoryserves]

if we know that they don't, why is there still discussion? lol

Because Andres likes to torture me.

[farley drexel hatcher]

They had to play to track on Top Of The Pops in 1994 - bands weren't allowed to play totally live at that point because so many were sounding awful. I've heard it and they're just playing live over the track. Just music, not vocals. They didn't seem too happy about it XD that's the only time i've ever seen them lip sync though.

[Kayfabe]

hm. I wouldn't listen to them. Or I would, like the 130487305 other fangirls who are magnified to sucky music

[Guest]

Video to Sassafras Roots. What you just described, but then driving in circles around a house.

bad humour, sorry

And I still don't know how to write Sassafras(s)... one or two S's in the end?

Sassafras Roots

I totally had to go into itunes to check

[Katarina.]

What if? There are no what if's. Green Day do suck.

Ahahaha

Interesting while saying that you're on a Green Day forum and you have over 8,000 posts.

[ScreamsInSilence815]

Pretty hypothetical question. We know they don't lip-sync, and if this they did, I'm sure plenty of people would be disappointed, considering we all know that they're more than capable of playing live.

This.

End of discussion.

If they did suck, I'd be ashamed to be a huge fan of theirs.

[Kayfabe]

you--me--outside.

NOW.

KICK HER ASS.

[Lauren]

breakdown is so fucking over produced it's ridiculous.

thank god they're a good live band.

[badwolf]

OMFG we have a non-believer here everybody

:o :o :o

you--me--outside.

NOW.

The Sarcastic Mary Strikes Again!

[Kayfabe]

if we know that they don't, why is there still discussion? lol

we know they don't but what if they did is the question. What if they were on par with Justin Bieber and the Jonas Brothers. Would you have gotten into them?