Which Version of Good riddance?

[BigYellowTaxi]

Oh def the electric from Bullet In a Bible. I have yet to still master the solo in the elec. version.

[Bastard of 1967]

A hard one, but I have to go for acoustic, especially the (MTV World Stage: ) Munich show version.

The enhanced picking beginning (he slides more notes there), the solo, and the rampaging strumming ...<3

That's probably *the* best live performance of Good Riddance that I've ever seen.

[FannyDefoe]

acoustic. but only when he does the solo. yknow what i mean? <3 wub: love it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PCdzRdg97Cg

me too

[Holly Ann]

Electric. That little solo/instrumental part in BIAB is my favourite piece of music in the whole word. I don't even know why...

[Marlon_GD]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PCdzRdg97Cg

Yes, I meant this one... just pure <3-ness

[ScreamsInSilence815]

Definitely the acoustic. There's just something about Billie picking up the acoustic and...Idek. There's just this feeling that comes over the audience that I can't describe.

/cheese

[fadi_7]

i love the Electric more but they are both good

[Maddy.]

I thoroughly prefer the electric version. The end of Bullet in a Bible is just amazing, I really tear up every time. It's beautifully played and it's the perfext ending to a show. The acoustic is almost boring, I can barely listen to it. The electric version has more life to it, I think, so that makes it more enjoyable to me.

[Lu_S]

Acoustic, it let the song more special and intimate.

[EuropeanIdiot]

Oh dear. Uhm... I think I would have to go with the acoustic version. Not that I don't like the electric version, because I prefer their hardcore stuff, but I think the electric guitar takes something away from this song. Uhm... like, both are amazing, but I think the acoustic guitar just... fits. <3

[Katarina.]

Right now I'd say acoustic. The super fast strumming and that solo he plays at the shows these days.. Ah, just :wub: Memories.

[Guest Whatsername95]

Hmm..

I love both versions, but I prefer the acoustic version. It reminds me of the awesome concerts I've been to .

[rebellionaire8]

I just think the electric version in bullet in a bible is amazing and the perfect way to close out the set. I honestly just prefer him with an electric over an acoustic, but that's just me

[Holly]

Acoustic all the way

[CoreyGregory]

I personally don't like that song. But I guess I respect the acoustic one more because it is more experimental for a Green Day song.

[JT of Suburbia]

electric

i do like acoustic

but 1st time i saw bullet in a bible version i was amazed XD

[Chad is Rad]

I really like the acoustic one, with his little solo thrown into it. It blew my mind.

[BringMoreKnives]

Acoustic

[Haniik]

Well... accoustic seems better for me...

[Heather!]

Hmmm, I don't really know which I like better.

When it comes to the recorded versions, I really love the one off of the Brainstew/Jaded single. Maybe I've just heard the version from Nimrod too often, but I prefer the tone of the single.

[ifmemoryserves]

I think Electric. When I first heard it live I was amazed. It was such a difference from the studio version.

[Polly1987]

Definitely the acoustic version. I could always cry when I hear the song.

[GloriasInferno]

Acoustic it's so beautiful.. but the electric version also is really powerful and just makes it a little bit better to me. So yeah, electric. But I love acoustic too.

[LinziLetterbomb]

Acoustic

[Pedestrian9394]

I think the electric version sounds really good, but there's something....sentimental about seeing them play it acoustic in concert. I was really hoping they would when I saw them in Georgia, and luckily they did. =D It was beautiful to hear it the way it was originally recorded. I think some songs are meant to be left one way and not tampered with, and Good Riddance is one of them for me.