She vs. When I Come Around

[JaninaStar]

She is the first GD song I ever heard, and it's still THE best for me.

[Smoothed Out]

When i come around

[Tubbie Head]

I voted for She... It wasn't too hard for me..

I think She deserves to win this one.. But I know it's not happening =(

BTW, I'm still not sure about tomorow.. But I think AI is going to be the winner.. I think the songs on this top aren't really their BEST songs, it's more like the fan favorite songs/ most popular songs...

Well, I know it's not possible to say which one is their best, and also know that people have different ways of avaliating a song, but I thought the top would be much better, considering we are in the Green Day Community! XD

[Metanoia]

I voted for She... It wasn't too hard for me..

I think She deserves to win this one.. But I know it's not happening =(

BTW, I'm still not sure about tomorow.. But I think AI is going to be the winner.. I think the songs on this top aren't really their BEST songs, it's more like the fan favorite songs/ most popular songs...

Well, I know it's not possible to say which one is their best, and also know that people have different ways of avaliating a song, but I thought the top would be much better, considering we are in the Green Day Community! XD

what is american idiot up against tomorrow ?

[fev5]

I went for She. I love that song!

[Guest]

When I Come Around

[Joy of suburbia.]

Alrighty...

after listening to both songs last night and today.

I'm ready to make my decision.

I love both songs to death.

I have an emotional attachment to She;

it got me through the extremlely bad patch

I had whne I was 15 and sums up my life perfectly

plus, it was played at both concerts I went to and

when I head it in DC...I cried.

When I Come Around is an amazing song

and I can't help feeling nostaglic and fuzzy when I hear it.

also, it was one of the songs that actually got me into Green Day.

But...She was one of the songs that actually kept me alive so I gotta go with that one.

I won't be mad if When I Come Around wins...not one bit.

[Jacob.]

what is american idiot up against tomorrow ?

Tomorrow's vote will be

21st Century Breakdown vs. American Idiot

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I voted for When I Come Around.

[misslyssx]

I went with When I Come Around although both songs are amazing

And I'm changing my mind as I write this I better make it quick haha

I'll be happy with either song winning on this one.

[Shirley']

She, definitely

[Holly]

I thought She would be winning this by a mile!? Yeah, When I Come Around is great.. but She is amazing! One of my top Green Day songs. Can't believe it is losing!

[GoodRiddanceGE]

Man that decision was nearly impossible...

I went with She nevertheless... It´s one of my favourite songs as you can tell by my sig.

It represents an important point of view concerning today´s society I think. That´s the point why She is a little bit more of a classic than WICA for me.

[Metanoia]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I voted for When I Come Around.

holy fuck thats gonna be the haRdest one for me so far thanks for posting again.......

[cherylr]

She was the first Green Day song I really liked. I could relate to it. And it made me take a closer look Green Day's lyrics.

[rocklover92]

Yeah. When I Come Around is the absolute winner 4 me.

[miky.in.a.broken.dream]

When I come around, for sure!!

[Eeefaa.]

She: eas-ay

just thinking purely of a certain madison square garden performance :whistling:

okay, so tomorrows vote will be easy too

im so surprised that she isnt winning

[gabbag]

I had to go with When I Come Around even though I love them both.

[Just Kate]

wow, i thought it's the easiest one but looks like a real song fight, damn... i stay with When I Come Around. i love the live version, there's that strange lovely vibe

[Kayfabe]

LOL so many people haven't voted because they can't decide. WICA is an eternal song, and She is not. So I'm gonna have to go with that. Heh awesome page own

[Nobody_Likes_You]

I got the words to both songs on my wall, but When I Come Around is such an AMAZING song, just because it is so simple and beautiful.

Glad it wins.

[ems]

This one is a toughie. I voted for WICA - as I put that in my top 10 songs and didn't put She in... so I'd be pretty stupid if I didn't vote for it!

Tomorrows vote is going to be interesting!

[Spark of Insanity]

Neither of them are my absolute favorites. But I chose "When I come Around" because I listen to it more and like it a bit better.

[Annie, get your gun]

For me this one is so easy!!!

Go WHEN I COME AROUND Go!!!

[Guest Charlotte.]

This one is easier for me to decide on than yesterday's! Still, not an easy decision...

She