Jump to content

She vs. When I Come Around

Trotsky

By Trotsky
in Green Day Chat

She vs. When I Come Around  

280 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Trina Dominated Love Slave

Trina

Posted
Posted

how won East Jesus Nowhere or GTP?

GTP!

I picked She. I love both equally so I'll give my vote to the current underdog, I guess.

I can always go back and change it later.

  • Replies 225
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Supermodel*Robot Dominated Love Slave

Supermodel*Robot

Posted
Posted

SHE.

GREAT SONG.

CHOO CHOO CHOOSE IT.

Bohemian+Scandal Pedestrian

Bohemian+Scandal

Posted
Posted

I've never been a big fan of She if I'm being completely honest.

It never quite hit me very hard.

When I Come Around most definitely. I still believe the first Green Day song I heard was Basket Case (vagulely), but the first video I saw was WICA and it was probably the first time I consciously saw Green Day. I knew nothing about them. I just remember thinking, "why are his pant legs so short?"

Guest Shangri-La

Guest Shangri-La

Posted
Posted

sleazing my backyard..

AleKerplunk Dominated Love Slave

AleKerplunk

Posted
Posted

GTP!

Dammit. i wanted EJN u.u

Supermodel*Robot Dominated Love Slave

Supermodel*Robot

Posted
Posted

sleazing my backyard..

scream at me until my ears bleed

i'm taking heed just for you

Bohemian+Scandal Pedestrian

Bohemian+Scandal

Posted
Posted

Mama's boy sweaters with the contradictory "rebellious" chain were popular in the mid to late nineties among the teenage guys from what I and my friend remember. I like to think that Billie Joe had a hand in this.

Supermodel*Robot Dominated Love Slave

Supermodel*Robot

Posted
Posted

I think She should have gotten a video. It's a spectacular song.

gone2pasalacqua Supermodel Robot

gone2pasalacqua

Posted
Posted

i like She but I just love When I Come Around. it's also my favorite Green Day music video.

megalopolis Welcome to Paradise

megalopolis

Posted
Posted

I love She, but absolutely no contest. WICA has a special place in my heart :wub: lol.

umbjisfhinefum Chump

umbjisfhinefum

Posted
Posted

when i come around.

the bass line (yea mike) makes my insides squirm and everytime this song starts i simply can not function for 3 minutes straight

i love she, but i dont think these two are on the same level AT ALL

Hanner Pedestrian

Hanner

Posted
Posted

this was hard. but i picked She.

and tbh i think the deciding factor was when he screams in She. :lol:

Mar Best Thing In Town

Mar

Posted
Posted

I am going to be so upset if "She" loses! It's my favorite GD song ever, it's perfect.

I know a lot of people love "When I Come Around" but for some reason, I was never the biggest fan of the song. :ninja:

bjrules Insomniac

bjrules

Posted
Posted

I love She, but When I Come Around is one of my favourite songs of all time, so I had to go with that.

Abstractication Brat

Abstractication

Posted
Posted

That was so hard!!! ButI finally ended up choosing She.

Trina Dominated Love Slave

Trina

Posted
Posted

WICA is probably one of my favorite music videos too.

Mama's boy sweaters with the contradictory "rebellious" chain were popular in the mid to late nineties among the teenage guys from what I and my friend remember. I like to think that Billie Joe had a hand in this.

I have an obsession with Billie Joe's sweater in the music video for WICA. Is it not thee most spectacular sweater, ever? :lol:

I think She should have gotten a video. It's a spectacular song.

Mhmm! I agree. It was even a hit on the US radio, i think!

boosho Pedestrian

boosho

Posted
Posted

This was very hard again.. I really love SHE coz it speaks to me alot.. and i relate to it soooo much.. But Fuck WICA is a better song.. :pinch:

So went with WICA

amy_runs Peacemaker

amy_runs

Posted
Posted

Come on She! Almost thereeeeeeee

leacalifornia Pedestrian

leacalifornia

Posted
Posted

I think She should have gotten a video. It's a spectacular song.

yes!!

I feel like this song just oozes Billie's amazing songwriting... :)

Of course I'm not saying that When I Come Around isnt good songwriting.. lol

ugh... double negatives..

:ninja:

gone2pasalacqua Supermodel Robot

gone2pasalacqua

Posted
Posted

WICA is probably one of my favorite music videos too.

I have an obsession with Billie Joe's sweater in the music video for WICA. Is it not thee most spectacular sweater, ever? :lol:

hahahhah it is. me and my friend SEPARATELY found sweaters that look like exactly like it in random thrift shops. pretty crazy.

Photo187.jpg

umbjisfhinefum Chump

umbjisfhinefum

Posted
Posted

hahahhah it is. me and my friend SEPARATELY found sweaters that look like exactly like it in random thrift shops. pretty crazy.

Photo187.jpg

'twas the same thrift shop BITCH

gone2pasalacqua Supermodel Robot

gone2pasalacqua

Posted
Posted

'twas the same thrift shop BITCH

really? i'm crazy. well it was different days BIZITCH!

umbjisfhinefum Chump

umbjisfhinefum

Posted
Posted

really? i'm crazy. well it was different days BIZITCH!

NO SHIT MENTAL RETARD

Johannamunter Insomniac

Johannamunter

Posted
Posted

This one is probably the toughest for me, so hard! I think that She is better songwriting but I like the melody of When I come around better,

I think I'm going to vote for when I come around

ANJI Peacemaker

ANJI

Posted
Posted

Damn this was so hard to choose...but i went with When i come around.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...