Who Wrote Holden Caulfield? vs. Minority

[karma1215]

I love Who Wrote Holden Caulfield but Minority is just amazing live.

Minority

[Burnout28]

Who Wrote Holden Caulfield!!!! all The Way babyy!!! =] gotta love that song.. i mean minority is amazing and all but y'know who wrote holden caulfield is hands down better! =]

[champagne mami]

I came to a conclusion...

They are both really awesome songs, but Who Wrote Holden Caulfield is amazing and better, imo.

So, I'm voting for Caulfield...

But whichever one wins, I'll be happy.

[Mellyboots]

I love them both, but Minority definitely.

[i_wanna_see_the_light]

Who wrote holden caulfield!!!

Minority is a very good song, too!

[Joy of suburbia.]

So...after listening to my continuious Holden Caulfield vs. Minority

playlist for like, 2 hours last night, I still couldn't decide on a song.

I decided to sleep on it and even though I love both songs

and even though I love Who Wrote Holden Caulfield to death...

I gotta vote for Minority.

I saw Minority live twice [which sounds amazing, by the way]

in all of it's epic-ness and it's basically an anthem of

going against the grain...which is like, the story of my life.

but I won't be upset if Who Wrote Holden Caulfield won, though.

[valentinesandcigs]

I gotta go with Minority.

[Kaddi.]

This is the hardest one I think. I just couldn't decide, so I flipped a coin and Who Wrote Holden Caulfield one, so yeah that's what I voted for.

[Punx89]

minority.

[Daughter.of.Rage.and.Love]

Minority. It's one of my favourite Green Day songs (also one of my favourite songs in general). Who Wrote Holden Caulfield is a nice song too, but Minority wins hands down.

[Li Sa]

Minority :wub I can't do anything to stop it ...voted

[Maddy.]

Minowwity

[Just Kate]

Holden Claufield all the way.

it has a real story behind it and reflects the book and billie's own life at the same time.

Minority is kinda fun but it gets old easily.

this

damn, Holden rules (i really love Minority though )

[GoodRiddanceGE]

Though I know that Who Wrote Holden Caulfield is Billies favourite song I´ll go with Minority. It´s just a classic. It gives me comfort to listen to it whenever I feel like an outsider. Because the song delivers the message that there´s a community of people like me feeling excactly the same.

[Agija]

Who Wrote Holden Caulfield is an amazing song, but I just like Minority much better. <3

[Guest]

That was harder than yesterdays, but I went for Minority

[incendiary girl]

I love both, but I had to go with Minority.

[Metanoia]

ok i gotta say that who wrote holden caulfield is one of my favs off kerplunk but this surely HAS to go to the incredible minority =)

[Ticcnluna]

I don't need your authority

I wanna vote for Minority!!

:whistling:

[Trotsky]

Tomorrow's vote will be Good Riddance vs. 2000 Light Years

[Maddy.]

^That's easy. For me. Good Riddance for the win. <33

[umbjisfhinefum]

i couldn't do it..i just couldn't do it

i love them both evenly and i would be glad to see either one win

Tomorrow's vote will be Good Riddance vs. 2000 Light Years

is that seriously even a competition? i love 2000 but really?

[Maddy.]

^Your sig is too big.

[Kaddi.]

Tomorrow's vote will be Good Riddance vs. 2000 Light Years

Aaaargh... could you please stop making it harder every day?!

[umbjisfhinefum]

Had to go with Minority. No matter what, when ever it comes on I just have to sing One light, one mind flashing in the dark, blinded by the silence of a thousand broken hearts, for crying out lond, she screamed unto me, a free for all, fuck 'em all, you are your own sight.

I don't think I've ever heard someone say fuck so melodically before...

that line is what made it so damn difficult!