Green Day: Worst to Best

[Vanilla Shake]

My order would have to be

1.) 21st Century Breakdown

2.) Insomniac

3.) Warning:

4.) nimrod.

5.) Dookie

6.) Shenanigans

7.) 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours

8.) Kerplunk!

9.) American Idiot

[madie]

This list is complete shite.

[Tiffx]

Nimrod is the best everything else follows.

[RebelofSuburbia]

Haven't heard 21CB yet so can't judge about that, but

7. Insomniac

6. 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours

5. Warning

4. Kerplunk

3. American Idiot

2. Dookie

1. Nimrod

[acevideogameadict]

No 1 has shenanighans on the list lol

[TheMinority]

Nimrod to me is better than Dookie, AI is better too.

Warning should be higher up and so should Insomniac...

I'm not much for the older albums to tell you the truth. But that's now maybe in a week it will change.

[.Holly]

8. 1039 Smooth

7. Insomniac

6. Kerplunk

5. Warning

4. Nimrod

3. 21CB

2. Dookie

1. American Idiot

Not a big fan of 1039 compared to the rest of the albums, but it's still better than most of the crap they play on the radio these days. American Idiot can never move from the top spot for me, and I love Dookie too much to bump it down. 21CB may move up the list after I've had enough time to absorb and appreciate it and after I've seen them play it on tour. Guess we'll have to wait and see...

[Yussef]

Warning - worst?

Naaah.

[novacaine_kid]

Nimrod deserves way more credit than that.

8. 39 smooth

7. Kerplunk

6. Warning

5. American Idiot

4. Nimrod

3. Insomniac

2. 21st Century Breakdown

1. Dookie

[musse]

Disagree. I can't say which one of their albums is the best, and none of the is the worst cause they're all so good. But at least I can say Warning is one of the best albums I've even seen (or heard, whatever).

[Princess Consuela]

Warning worst than 39/Smooth? No way. And Nimrod should definitely be higher. I won't make my list, it'd take a while

And right now I'd put 21st CB on the top of the list

[Haushinkaholic]

Nimrod = Best

Insomniac=2nd

Dookie and Warning and 1039 and Kerplunk= Joint 3rd

American Idiot = a very close 4th

Nimrod way out in front for me, with Insomniac quite a bit ahead of 3rd place.

The gap between all of the others is practically microscopic.

Having said that, they are all much better than almost every other album ever made.

[Eirik]

Warning's last? I personally believe it's one of their best. Nice how they put the two most famous albums in the top two spots.

Yeah, and put the oldest one first, to get more street cred.

[teqi]

8. 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours

7. Insomniac

6. American Idiot

5. Kerplunk

4. 21st Century Breakdown

3. Dookie

2. Nimrod

1. Warning

well my list is completely different than theirs! difficult to rank them, especially 3-5. I don't really consider any of them "worst"; I like them all in different ways. 21st Century Breakdown may move up, just too early to tell yet.

[Peel Slowly And See]

http://music.ign.com/articles/982/982099p1.html

7. Warning

6. 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours

5. Nimrod

4. Insomniac

3. Kerplunk

2. American Idiot

1. Dookie

Agree or disagree? Where do you think 21st Century Breakdown will fit?

7. 39/Smooth

6. Kerplunk

5. Nimrod

4. Dookie

3. American Idiot

2. Insomniac

1. Warning:

Fixed to holy god damned hell.

[Micky]

Disagree

7. 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours

6. Kerplunk

5. Warning

4. Insomniac

3. Dookie

2. American Idiot

(21th Century Breakdown)

1. Nimrod

[Katarina.]

I don't agree with this at all.

Nimrod should've been at least in the top 3. And Warning worst? Oh no. It's a great album, it doesn't deserve to be last. Like this:

7. 39/Smooth

6. Insomniac

5. Dookie

4. American Idiot

3. Kerplunk

2. Warning

1. Nimrod

But tbh, I can't really say one of the album's the 'worst'. I think it's better to say That Nimrod for me's on #1, the three after that are equal #2, and the last three are equal #3.

I love them all!

[Elis_x]

Nimrod deserves way more credit than that.

8. 39 smooth

7. Kerplunk

6. Warning

5. American Idiot

4. Nimrod

3. Insomniac

2. 21st Century Breakdown

1. Dookie

I agree with this one

[rinu]

Kerplunk and Insomniac would be replaced

[Hermione]

Ha even though I already ranked them 1-7, really it'd be more accurate to say...

Nimrod, Dookie, American Idiot - equal 1st place

Insomniac, Kerplunk, Warning - equal 2nd place

39/Smooth - 3rd place

But all fabulous . If I was going to include side bands, Money Money 2020 would be in with 3rd place, and Stop Drop and Roll would be in with 1st place

[Haushinkaholic]

Ha even though I already ranked them 1-7, really it'd be more accurate to say...

Nimrod, Dookie, American Idiot - equal 1st place

Insomniac, Kerplunk, Warning - equal 2nd place

39/Smooth - 3rd place

But all fabulous . If I was going to include side bands, Money Money 2020 would be in with 3rd place, and Stop Drop and Roll would be in with 1st place

I like you.

[Ally]

i would say

8.1039 smoothed out slappy

7.Insomniac

6.Kerplunk

5.Nimrod

4.Warning

3.American Idiot

2.Dookie

1. 21st Century Breakdown

but that changes on a daily basis, depending what i've been listening to. foxboro hot tubs would come between dookie and 21stCB, and network would be the very last cos i dont like them as the network at all.

But all fabulous . If I was going to include side bands, Money Money 2020 would be in with 3rd place, and Stop Drop and Roll would be in with 1st place

yeah i think i agree with that but for me network would be 4th place i think, rather than joint 3rd!

[wwnflat_punk]

1. 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours

2. Kerplunk

3. Dookie

4. Insomniac

5. Shenanigans

6. Nimrod

7. Warning

8. American Idiot

* "21st Century Breakdown" may come after or before AI, haven't listened to it yet.

[Guest 16PaperLanterns]

7. 1039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours

6. Insomniac

5. Kerplunk

4. Warning

3. Dookie

2. American Idiot

(21st Century Breakdown)

1. Nimrod

probably, but it changes from time to time.

[The Disappearing Boy]

disagree