Dearlybeloved666* Posted March 13, 2007 Posted March 13, 2007 it matters if the music they play is good or not.it doesn't matter if they are punk, pop, ectr.
cam-greenday-fan Posted March 13, 2007 Posted March 13, 2007 whoo i have never thought of this i think there in a league of there own or there music satin would lsten to in the showerwhoo i have never thought of this i think there in a league of there own or there music satin would lsten to in the shower
Trotsky Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 Do all of you realize that you can say Green Day isn't punk yet still think they are a great band?Just because they aren't punk doesn't mean they suck, they just aren't punk.
emi_sarb Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 I think a lot of people say that Green Day sold out because it is the cool thing to do at the moment. This article is mainly about The offspring but I think this quote is interesting. He would see these kids come in and buy Dookie and Smash,” Noodles explains. “A couple months later they’d buy Mr. T Experience, Op Ivy and NOFX and Pennywise. Three months later, they were coming in and getting Crass and Adolescents and Dead Kennedys. He’d remark ‘I remember just a couple months ago, you bought Green Day and Offspring.’ They’d be ‘Fuck Green Day! Fuck Offspring! Those guys are sellouts!’ Then again, our band and Green Day, all the bands who were coming up in that scene have definitely tried to give credit where credit is due and credit those bands that came before us and inspired us to do what it is we do.”I don't care if Green Day are punk or not because I don't like a band because they are punk, I like a band because I like the music.
Krusties Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 Does it really matter if Green Day is punk or not?
chickin'pickin' Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 This debate is as redundant as a condom with a hole in it, it will never be resolved, and i dont really care.but for me, green day aren't punk.
St_Jimmy_10 Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 As long as they make great music, I don't give two shits if they're punk or not.
*withoutadoubt* Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 That was even better to read a second time, Angeline.
xxx Sarah xxx Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 Who care's how 'punk' they are? They're still fantabulous.Punk is a state of mind, so there's no way to really judge
goodday Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 That was even better to read a second time, Angeline. I second that :wink:
justcause Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 I second that :wink:Thanx so much for reading, Patricia - and Cheryl too!
14razorbacks Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 Yeah, Green Day make punk music sometimes.They also make rock, pop, bits of ska, some acoustic.They have punk in mind at all times, that I believe. They're just pushing the boundaries of what they should do. Just because they are able to make two minute thrash songs, doesn't mean they have to spend twenty odd years making two minute thrash songs and only two minute thrash songs.
Used Illusion2 Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 the reason green day are great is cos they can write awt and make it brilliant...
FJ Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 Punk died with The Clash, but it was terminally ill since Sid Vicious died.And Green Day aren't punk. Sure, they were at the start, but it soon changed into punk-rock.
mr.fender Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 i love their music, i don´t care if it´s punk, pop or rock or whatever..
Marc. Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 who cares anymore seriously there kinda not filling us in on whats happening and yer the moneys gone to the head i think
FJ Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 there kinda not filling us in on whats happening and yer the moneys gone to the head i thinkYeah, they're the typical rich rock star. Coke parties, mansions, always in the tabloid scandal pages. And if they kept stopping to keep everyone updated, the album wouldn't be out until 2010. Besides, what's to be updated on except 'they're working on a new album'?
Marc. Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 Yeah, they're the typical rich rock star. Coke parties, mansions, always in the tabloid scandal pages. And if they kept stopping to keep everyone updated, the album wouldn't be out until 2010. Besides, what's to be updated on except 'they're working on a new album'?never know one of em mightve left and they couldnt be fucked to tell us or they split up
Darkshine Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 Who care's how 'punk' they are? They're still fantabulous.Punk is a state of mind, so there's no way to really judgeu're righti think GD mixes some music styles and the result is always great!! they are very talented guys))
Dearlybeloved666* Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 if they were considered polka i'd still love them.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.