Would Green Day be where they are if American Idiot was their first and only album?

[penutt]

they would be remembered as great because of the potential they had, and what they could've done. AI is my second least fav album from gd, but its the best one. if that makes sense.

FUCK the media FUCK mtv FUCK all the teenies

I wouldn't have as much respect for them if that was there first but I can't say what is unknown :/

NO OFFENCE WTF?! offened those little bastards NO one likes them so I've said it once I'll say it again

FUCK all the teenies

goddamit. shut up.

[The-Enemy]

Simply, no. They kinda had to build up to American Idiot. But if they were magically that good etc. then yeah sure why not.

[Maru]

if they would appear like that from nowhere at all...being in their mid 30`s....they would've been LAME....