Jump to content

Green Day without Billie, Mike and Tré


Guest jesus of suburbia25

Recommended Posts

Posted

Green Day without Billie Joe, Mike or Tre would totally suck

Er ..well they wouldn't be as great or kick ass.

  • Replies 114
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

Green Day Would Not Be Green Day With them 3! :D

Posted

If Green Day had never been Billie, Mike or Tre, and the music sounded exactly the same as it does now, I'm sure I'd like them just as much.

(Ignoring the fact that this question is pointless, since we would never know Billie, Mike or Tre anyway if they had never been in the band. Green Day would be exactly the same, just made up of different people.)

Posted

GD minus billie joe, mike and tre. there would be no green day.

Posted

If one of them left/died (touch wood!) I hope Green Day don't go on. They're like the three musketeers; one for all and all for one!

Posted

well this question is a bit stupid from my point of view

because if all three members were not in green day

then the lyircs and the music would most likely be different

there would be no way 3 other guys would have made the same music as bj mike and tre

no other guy would have written the exact lyrics as bj did/does

or wrote the exact same melody to their songs.

so you can't really say if you would like green day's songs but by different members

because it wouldn't have happened.

Posted

this would then be a different band. So there is no way to say.

Posted

I think I'd like the band but it wouldn't be the same thing at all, I mean Tré, Mike and Billie Joe have success thanks to their music but also for who they are

Posted

It wouldn't be the same music without all three of them, nor would it be Green Day.

true.. same opinion

Posted

Green Day wouldn't been Green Day because all the songs are about their experiances and things and not everyone has exactly the same experiances. THEY ARE GREEN DAY!!!!!!!! If you got rid of them it wouldn't be the same Green Day. The songs wouldn't be the same. Also they're unique humans, we're all unique, so you'd never find any one exactly like them. Its a pointless question really.

  • 3 months later...
Posted

it would be just a typical punk-rock band

Posted

It wouldn´t be the same. Look, without Billie Joe :wub: there isn´t a vocalist. Without Mike, there isn´t a bassist and without Tré, there isn´t a drummer. So? Without one of them Green Day doesn´t exist

Posted

Without Billie, Tre and Mike, it wouldn't been Green Day, Green Day wouldn't exist.

Posted

Green Day is Green Day.....no Billie would = no Green Day...no Mike would = no Green Day...of course the crazy lunitic Tre..w/o him...there would be no fucking Green Day....

Posted

PERTY GOOD JUST NOT AS GOOD

Posted

QUOTE(jnine13 @ Feb 3 2006, 10:04 PM)

It wouldn't be the same music without all three of them, nor would it be Green Day.

^^i agree with this :)

Posted

idk really i mean they are green day

Posted

Billie, Mike, and Tre are Green Day.

Posted

If Billie Joe, Mike, or Tre weren't in Green Day, then it wouldn't be Green Day. I don't think anyone can definitely know if they would like Green Day if other people were in the band because that has not happened. Everything would be different and it wouldn't be Green Day as we know it.

Posted

You know, I think I would like Green Day if Billie Joe, Tre and Mike weren't in the band, even though it's not possible for the band to be the same, without the guys.

But I'll ignore that. You see, if BJ, Mike and Tre wouldn't be in Green Day from the first place, you wouldn't KNOW them and then you won't feel the difference. this is a hard question though.

But I'm really happy that Billie Joe, Mike and Tre are in Green Day. They have a really great personality, and that's not an easy thing to say since I don't even know them personally.

Edit:

Oh, but I definitely know that I'll like the band LESS if the guys weren't in it.

They are a really big part of my love to Green Day.

Posted

omg that is a great question, hard to answer...

Eh, i guess i will propably love the music etc, but i won't be so objessed without Mike... he is amazing...

plus for me green day are important not only for the music but for the attitude and their lives... their whole idenity, cause that does the music.

Music and character are correlative...

it would be just a typical punk-rock band

i am really sorry but, you know, green day are not a punk-rock band. :/ honestly. :)

Posted

It wouldn't be the same music without all three of them, nor would it be Green Day.

Damn right!!!

Posted

I'd still love green day..

I mean..who knows.

Maybe if there wasn't Billie, mike and tre..

maybe we wouldn't have so many little 12 year olds

as there fans and screaming 'they are lyke so freakin hawt'

You know..

But who cares.. we all love them...their music..whatever same thing..

:mellow: But it wouldn't be Green Day without all of them...

<shrugs>

Posted

Green Day without billie joe, mike, or tre..................is nothing at all, so there would be nothing to love.

Posted

all very confusing indeed, the music wouldnt be the same if it werent billie mike and tre doing it, however, if it where, say 3 other people and the music was exactly the same i would like it,

also the only reason i like billie mike and tre, is cuz they are green day,

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...