Leaderboard

I have to agree. I'm sure both women are talented singers, but that song was just never meant to be sung that way. It just didn't work.

The brothers at Billie's wedding!

Totally agree. While AAF has an amazing setlist, there are five things that kill it for me compared to BIAB: 1. The mixing. BIAB just sounds more powerful, somehow. 2. Billie's voice. I like that it sounds more raw on BIAB, and even though we've had this conversation many times, I still think that the vocals on AAF sound fucked-with at places. 3. The fact that BIAB is all from one concert gives it a more consistent feel. 4. Comparing the DVDs, the outdoor setting of BIAB makes it feel much less claustrophobic than the arena in AAF. 5. Best versions of "Brain Stew" and "Minority" ever.

WOW that thing better wipe their asses for them.

Tre Cool posted a picture of our very own Liam on instagram! Liam is the small one there. Congrats Liam!

Macy's Day Parade is 2nd behind Castaway easily for me. Simply one of their best songs. That middle section of the AAF CD, C&V-Who Wrote Holden Caulfield? is an incredible stretch. Also Demolicious could give us an interesting new twist on some trilogy songs. But to suggest that it would be better than any full-length LP that GD has put out, let along better than 21cb, is ridiculous. State of Shock would have to be better than Jesus of Suburbia for that to happen (it won't)

I don't know if this is an Unpopular Opinion or not but, Insomniac is way better than Dookie.

I don't think it's going to count as a Green Day album technically. It'll be more along the lines of Shenanigans and International Superhits.

Baby Eyes isnt even half as good as Christians Inferno...

Do you have ever actually heard 21st Century Breakdown? Because you seem a bit confused.

Nuclear Family would have been a much better opener than 99 Revs. I think the countdown at the end would have worked pretty well.

What about it? Oh, I forgot X-Kid, add that to the list. 99 Revolutions is just a world of no.

As much as I adore JOS (I mean, I don't even need to go into all the reasons why it's outstanding, do I?) I can kind of understand why people might not like it. It's unquestionably massively overblown, so if you're not into that kind of thing then something like Sweet 16 is bound to appeal more. /uncharacteristically diplomatic post

Lazy to edit images? Pfft... Next time you want to be funny, do something like this:

i agree with you, I think Insomniacs the best album they ever did.

I usually end up picking a song I want to listen to from the album, then end up leaving it on from that point. I almost never sit down and go Nice Guys to Prosthetic Head. On the other hand, I do this more often than not not with 21CB

Even though Nimrod is brilliant. I never feel like putting it on.

Jinx-Hausinka-Walking Alone-KFAD-Good Riddance And Worry Rock - Platypus - Uptight Eh, let's just say the whole album while we're at it

Almost every song's good on Nimrod. One of my fav albums.

Last Ride In is magical BiaB was a better concert, but AAF has better songs. The CD version has to be one of my favorite track lists ever - dat middle section! Holden Caulfield, JAR, Pasalacqua, and Cigarettes and Valentines

Today is Billie Joe's Mom Birthday!!:

Scattered is probably the best song on Nimrod...

I kind of count Shenanigans as a real album even though it technically may not be. International obviously doesn't count though. I've got an opinion that may be unpopular: BIAB is hands down the best live recording of Green Day ever, there's moments on that album that are so raw and powerful yet others are so beautiful it gives me chills. And I think it's got the best recording of Good Riddance ever

Well we all know how they get the shits on the road. Need to be comfortable for your pre-performance dookies I suppose... DIVAS.

If an album was made up of Brutal Love, Missing You, Stay The Night, X-Kid, 8th Avenue Serenade, Rusty James, Lazy Bones, Wow That's Loud! It'd be one of the strongest Green Day albums.

Yeah. She's got talent, but the song shouldn't be sung in that way.

I don't particularly like it but you have to admit, the guitar in the chorus and the solo are killer.

i hope there wont be tambourine on the demos

Are the upcoming eps of TJMS Tré and Jason's? Jeff Matika ‏@jeffmatika 14h Yes. Coming soon! “ lauren ‏@theatticdemos 4m AJ is saying Green Day are going on an indefinite hiatus but last night Billie said they will definitely come back to a Adelaide..... ?.?.? Jacqui Rose ‏@No1Animallover 23m ❤️This Night Will Forever Be The Love Of My Life❤️ cameron adams ‏@cameron_adams Feb 25 In hotel foyer overhearing Duff and Green Day discuss how soft their hotel beds are. Rock and roll has changed, man

russell_183 43 minutes ago #greenday #adelaide #soundwave

Nimrod is full of great songs, but that run of The Grouch, Redundant and Scattered is absolutely unbeatable.

Jinx is the best song on Nimrod.

"Heroes and cunts" he sounds like a lady in that bit.

On the subject of the Trilogy, is there anyone else who can't stand Fuck Time? I never understood all the hype about it.

I think I said in the main thread, I'm convinced these demos will be better than the originals!

I don't think it's unpopular, but I agree. It's actually my favorite song from the entire Trilogy. Kill the DJ is new for Green Day, I'll give it that, but that's about it. It's still a pretty fun song, though. I think the lyrics are the main reason I don't like it. I much prefer the version heard in ¡Cuatro!.

Here we go: Jess is actually really good. I don't think much of Anna, though.

Uno is slowly growing on me, actually. I now like Nuclear Family, Stay The Night, Carpe Diem, Let Yourself Go, Kill The DJ, Fell For You, Sweet 16 and Oh Love to varying degrees. I still hate the rest of the songs on it, and don't even get me started on Dos.

I didn't even make it! :lol: <3

And Billie and Chris Dugan on a hot date...

In Production Billie Joe & Norah "Kentucky" (Tim Wheeler, dir.) Featuring surfer Kassia Meador... http://www.videostatic.com/production/2014/02/25/billie-joe-norah-kentucky-tim-wheeler-dir