She vs. When I Come Around

[Trotsky]

Two Dookie songs face off. I have no idea which we'll take this one, actually.

[Heather!]

I need to think about this one, it's probably the hardest choice so far for me.

[Lyz Z]

Can't decide right now. I'll really need to think about it

[Rebel07]

I went with She :/

I hate this

[Guest x-Green Day-x]

Gosh, I hate having to vote for Green Day songs. :/

This is really tough... Mmmmm....

In the end, I have to go with When I Come Around.

But I love all Green Day songs the same

[newsflash777]

OH THAT'S FUNNY IF YOU THINK I CAN CHOOSE.

[GDM]

Woah... this one is impossible to decide... though I'm leaning toward She.

Gonna have to think about this one for the night.

[TaylorKlinke]

I absouluty LOVE both songs but I've named When I Come Around (and Jesus of Suburbia) my 2 favorite Green DAy songs, multiple times before. So I'm gonna have to go with that. But I love She too!

[biwic]

She won my vote. Both great songs, obviously

[Alex.]

Hardest choice so far, but i've gotta go with When I Come Around.

[*withoutadoubt*]

As much as I love When I Come Around, to me there is no contest on which is the better song. Maybe it's just me? but I think She is just such an incredible song.

[Angie-Marie]

Damn, this is probably the hardest pairing so far. I went with She, but I love both songs so much.

[Joy of suburbia.]

Alright...

I'm about to make the When I Come Around vs. She playlist

on iTunes and make a continious loop...yet again.

I really can't decide right now.

I love both songs dearly and I really can't choose one at the moment...

I think I'm gonna sleep on it....hopefully I can make a decision later on tonight.

gosh...this is so fucking hard. :/

[Agija]

She, for sure. I like it so much that there's no doubt which song to vote for.

[amy_runs]

This is the first toughie. But I went with She.

[AleKerplunk]

OMFG! my 2 favorites songs of Dookie D:!! but i voted for WICA. i love that song so much u.u

[insomniaticnimrod]

i decided to go with she

[norcalgreendayfan]

Gotta go with WICA on this one, it was one of the first videos for Green Day I saw on TV way back when and helped me get in to the best band ever

[gdpony]

I just had a little stroke thinking this through ...

she is great, when I come around too, they´re just different ... I hate choosing, but ..

when I come around gets my vote! ... its just pure green day!

I hope im not the only one that had a hard time chosing between the two ... -_-

[Foxboro Hot Tubs]

ok, so I think this will probably the first time I won't vote ...

I just really can't ..

I love both of those songs exactly the same. I have such a strong connection with both of them. I just can't vote.

I'm really curious how this round will end!

[Trina]

I have to give this some thought because I really don't know.

I love both songs dearly. They're definitely in my favorites. They really seem to be equal to me.

WICA is a better song in general but She would have a bit more emotional relevance to me; even though WICA does too!

fuck. I honestly don't know. I really can't decide!!

[AleKerplunk]

how won East Jesus Nowhere or GTP?

[Greenday_Aussie]

Pfft. Easiest yet. WICA was my first Green Day song, plus its better anyway

[alaniluau]

She has never quite touched me the way WICA does (and She doesn't have a music video featuring a very young, handsome Jason White).

[incendiary girl]

I probably shouldn't have clicked on this when I'm so tired. I thought I had already decided that I was going with "She", but now I'm torn all over again. Putting two Dookie songs against each other is just mean.

Sleeping on it. I'll pick tomorrow.