Scaruffi Criticize the new album

[parinaz]

for those who don't know Piero Scaruffi ,he is an Italian critic and writer. the thing that made me open a thread about this is because he is a very professional critic in music and I followed his critics about Green Day till a few months ago but when I checked his website today I got a new update about 21st century breakdown.

although some other professional critics like Pitchfork or sputnik music didn't rate the new album so high we can be optimistic about this one

so check it out here.

[Guest Shangri-La]

i like what he had to say even if his ratings suck. thanks parinaz

[parinaz]

you're welcome. well he is ssoooo strict in rating and we should be so thankful about his rating about the new album a 6/10 rating is something like Rolling stone's 9/10

He rated the bands like Muse Radiohead coldplay and U2's new album almost less than 5.

[Guest Shangri-La]

this guy hates music, probably.

[RobyRoom]

Thanks for the link, glad he likes the refrain of Little girl, is one of my favorite as well

[The Disappearing Boy]

nice review. surprised he didn't metniton the static age

[parinaz]

and 21 guns as well.

I wish I could understand the previous reviews as well.

[cherylr]

Actually, it seems like he likes it. I agree with him about "Last Night on Earth". The first time I heard it, I thought "sounds like John Lennon." "Peacemaker" doesn't sound like Country & Western to me. It sounds like I'm at someone's Bar Mitzvah. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE "Peacemaker".

[GDM]

Actually, it seems like he likes it. I agree with him about "Last Night on Earth". The first time I heard it, I thought "sounds like John Lennon." "Peacemaker" doesn't sound like Country & Western to me. It sounds like I'm at someone's Bar Mitzvah. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE "Peacemaker".

A Mexican bar mitzvah! And yes, I love Peacemaker, too. I think my head would explode if I heard them play it live.

Thanks, Parinaz, I'll check out the review.

[cherylr]

A Mexican bar mitzvah! And yes, I love Peacemaker, too. I think my head would explode if I heard them play it live.

Thanks, Parinaz, I'll check out the review.

I've told myself that I'll see them in New York next time rather than DC. Perhaps we could get together and entice them to play Peacemaker on the promise that they'd have two 45-year-old women with their heads exploding.

[i_wanna_see_the_light]

Maybe a classical piece gets a higher rate than a rock song

But well, he didn't write a negative thing about it!

[Peace and Rainbows]

what a dumbfuck

I don't think that dude likes music

Oh well

Entertaining read

[HoneyDo666]

I adore 21CB! It gets a 10/10 anyday!

Also, I think it's more ambitious than AI. More experimentation.

[Sharmellow]

Glad he at least likes some of the songs off of 21stCB. I attempted to read the other ones through google translation, but half of it didn't make sense. xD

[parinaz]

what would you say about this then?

edit: I just realized i have a misspelling in the title.

[Guest]

At least he's honest, unlike other reviews where they just say it's dreadful or say it's amazing.

[parinaz]

well I think he's as one of those critics who doesn't sell the good criticism for money.

[Guest]

Definatley xD

[Smoothed Out]

I found that quite interesting, thanks for posting Parinaz

[Conspiracy.]

what would you say about this then?

edit: I just realized i have a misspelling in the title.

xD. I kinda love this. How negative it is all the time. When I read the first sentence, I had to laugh so hard! I mean, seriously, "Green Day is dead." WTF?!? Amusing.

[Sharmellow]

what would you say about this then?

edit: I just realized i have a misspelling in the title.

Omg. Ahaha, that was actually pretty amusing, then again, it's sputnik.

My favorite line:

21st Century Breakdown sounds less like a Green Day record and more like a parody, except no one is laughing.

[Prisca]

Thanks for posting. I'll check it out before I start studying for my finals.

[Nikki_Nimrod]

Thanks for posting, that was definitely interesting I like reading reviews, especially if they're well thought out like that. (even though i may not agree with it!)

[Hermione]

what a dumbfuck

I don't think that dude likes music

I agree.

what would you say about this then?

Haha

[Guest Shangri-La]

what would you say about this then?

edit: I just realized i have a misspelling in the title.

"He Adam Downered his original assessment."

that comment alone made it worth reading haha