Rating Green Day

[andy4]

I just wanted to know what you all thought about everyone in Green Day. On how skilled they each are with their intruments. Rate them on a scale of 1-10 with 10 being the Best. Rate: Bille Joe, Mike, Tre and Al Sobrante. Sorry if nobody likes this thread. :whistling:

BJ: 8

Mike: 7

Tre: 8.5

Al: 6.5

[TréCoolrox]

Good topic lol

So

Billie Joe : 10

Mike : 8

Tré : 10

Al : 5 cuz i didn't fuck him

[Laura.]

Mike: 9/10

BJ: 7/10

Tre: 7/10

[angie]

Billie 10\10

Tre' 8\10

Mike 8\10

[Peter.]

Tré: 8

Mike: 6

Billie: 7

Al: 3.5

[Vanessa]

Billie: 10. I believe he has a lot lot more skill than he uses in his songs

Mike: 10. Best bass player in the history of punk rock.

Tre: 10. Hes awesome at banging drumming.

[andy4]

Tré: 8

Mike: 6

Billie: 7

Al: 3.5

3.5, that's low.

[Guest 16PaperLanterns]

billie: 8

tre: 9

mike: 7

[Peter.]

3.5, that's low.

Yes...what do you expect...listen to the intro fill to Why do you want him...listen to the hi-hat on most songs...he didn't do very good on that record...

[andy4]

Yes...what do you expect...listen to the intro fill to Why do you want him...listen to the hi-hat on most songs...he didn't do very good on that record...

He's too poor I guess...

[Cassie.]

BJ: 9.5

Tre:10

Mike:10

[TréCoolrox]

He's too poor I guess...

it's not a question of money it's just Tré is better than Al that it ....

[VictimOfAuthority]

billie:8

mike: 8

tre: 10

[Peter.]

nm

[andy4]

it's not a question of money it's just Tré is better than Al that it ....

I meant at buying a good hi-hat, you can't really be much better than anyone when normally playing one.

[Peter.]

it's not a question of money it's just Tré is better than Al that it ....

we're not comparing Al and Tré..we're viewing Johns achievement on 39/Smooth

[TotalBasketCase13]

Billie: 8.5/10

Mike: 9/10

Tre: 9/10

Al: 4/10

[TréCoolrox]

we're not comparing Al and Tré..we're viewing Johns achievement on 39/Smooth

yep in o sorry i'm just dead tired but i think Tré is better than Al

[Peter.]

I meant at buying a good hi-hat, you can't really be much better than anyone when normally playing one.

I'm not aiming at the sound in the hi-hat..i'm thinking of how 'un-tight' he is..he has no control whether it's open or closed and such..

[goodday]

rate them?....well, i don't think im able to do that...to me they are 10, because I love them

[Peter.]

yep in o sorry i'm just dead tired but i think Tré is better than Al

Yes he is..

[andy4]

I'm not aiming at the sound in the hi-hat..i'm thinking of how 'un-tight' he is..he has no control whether it's open or closed and such..

Oh, I get what you mean now, I think the songs are supposed to be like that though.

[Anko]

billie: guitat:10 voice:10

mike:bass:10 voice:10

tre: drums:10 voice:8

al:1.5

[Peter.]

Oh, I get what you mean now, I think the songs are supposed to be like that though.

nah man i highly doubt that you aim for un-tightness while making a record..i think it's a mix of he not having enough skills and not enough time to nail it all better..

[andy4]

nah man i highly doubt that you aim for un-tightness while making a record..i think it's a mix of he not having enough skills and not enough time to nail it all better..

I think he has the skills and more, I just think he likes playing like that in some of his songs. Even with Isocracy and the Ne'er Do Wells, his songs sound like that.