Welcome to Green Day Community

Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to contribute to this site by submitting your own content or replying to existing content. You'll be able to customize your profile, receive reputation points as a reward for submitting content, while also communicating with other members via your own private inbox, plus much more! This message will be removed once you have signed in.

A fellow GDCer needs your help!  See how you can help here.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
pasalaska

Song of the Week Oh Love (Song of the Week)

107 posts in this topic

Damn. I nominate Bastard for "best poster ever" when the next GDC awards roll around. Seriously, every time I see that you posted I am excited to read it. :lol: You guys did an awesome job with the lyrics too.

Also I love the song. It's easy and fun to listen to and is getting me very pumped up for Uno so I'm happy.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Michael, Melissa and Tanya for your interpretation. Awesome, really really awesome. And yes, I now also know, and understand, why this song has stuck with me and resonated in my brain.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Damn. I nominate Bastard for "best poster ever" when the next GDC awards roll around. Seriously, every time I see that you posted I am excited to read it. :lol: You guys did an awesome job with the lyrics too.

Also I love the song. It's easy and fun to listen to and is getting me very pumped up for Uno so I'm happy.

I don't get how he ever ended up with a post/rep ratio of only about 2/1… Always a nice read!

I'm a sucker for probably too complicated and far fetched song meanings :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You've definitely put a lot of thought into that, Bastard. The problem is, either you're reading too much into the lyrics or Bille Joe is expressing himself in an uncharacteristically hamfisted way. People seem keen to link the themes and carefree nature of the song to those in 39 and Kerplunk, but almost all of those songs were far more lucid than Oh Love. The sentiments were simple, true, but they at least flowed in some sense. The best dismissal I've seen of these new lyrics is that they read like a page of first lines, with nothing to link them to one another.

Since it just happens to be playing, consider the lyrics of Dry Ice. He was still a teenager when he wrote it, so the universal themes - love, yearning, uncertainty - are expressed in fairly simplistic terms. All the same, the lines represent perfectly understandable poetry. Verse two: "I'll send a letter to that girl asking her to be my own / But my pen is writing wrong, so I'll say it in a song / Oh I love you more right now, more than I've ever loved before / Here are those words straight from these lips, I'll need you forever more".

Compare that sentence, flowing and beautiful in its youthful elegance, to verse two of Oh Love: "Oh lights and action, I just can't be satisfied / Oh losers and choosers, won't you please hold on my life? / Oh hours and hours, like the dog years of the day / Old story same old story, won't you see the light of day?"

The first sentence makes no sense in the context you suggest. If Billie is trying to express dissatisfaction at his current place in life, then the juxtaposition with 'oh lights and action' is muddled and backwards; as structured, it reads like the lights and action are unable to satisfy him. Then comes the second part which, ironically, you had to add your own punctuation to. Even in edited form, "won't you please hold on, my life?" is woeful writing that almost trips over its own inept phrasing. The dog years part is fine, if awkward, but the final sentence is merely another meaningless platitude. Presumably he is willing [the narrator] to 'see the light of day', in which case an editor (Rob?) really should have taken a marker to his shitty sentence construction. Read the entire stanza out loud, and tell me any of it flows properly.

Billie may well be trying to express something profound here, but it reads like he simply pulled lines from a hat and arranged them randomly on the page. I've come to enjoy the song a bit more over the last couple of days (particularly as an anthemic chaser before Dos) and I applaud your efforts to make sense of it, but the wider context reveals only scattergun, throwaway lyrics. I'd argue that's what you might expect Billie to toss off while drunk one night in the studio, if only the majority of Foxboro songs weren't considerably more profound, erudite and cohesive.

3 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't get how he ever ended up with a post/rep ratio of only about 2/1 ... Always a nice read!

Easy - the other half of stuff that I post is usually a load of crap! :lol:

Seriously - Thank you all for the positive feedback on these posts. I'm humbled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Michael, Melissa and Tanya for this brilliant interpretation! I really really really enjoyed reading it. :wub::happy:

bj_bowing.gif

this is basically me, worshiping your talent for writing & interpretations.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I appreciate your thoughts, and if this were an English class I'd say you have some really good points there. Hell, I still think you have some good points there regardless. But I'd argue this is poetry we're looking at -- and very dense, vague, and condensed poetry at that. So I'll agree it's going to fall flat for some people, as did some of BJ's songwriting on 21st Century Breakdown. That it's not falling flat with everyone -- and instead is having the opposite effect -- suggests that the meat he's packing into this song is (maybe even despite his best efforts?) making it to the surface.

As for the comparison between the straighforward, almost prosaic, style Billie used in the 39/Smooth and Kerplunk days, to his writing on 21stCB and now what little we've seen of Uno, I'd suggest that he's just using a much more stream-of-consciousness and metaphoric style now. If his language were art, it would be more like an impressionist painting or a watercolor than a landscape portrait. It's very artistic, and it's a *lot* harder to "get" because its plain meaning doesn't hit you in the face like his writing did when he was a teenager. Some may say the quality of his songs will suffer because of this, but I feel it elevates them.

3 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From my own pov, I have no desire to be 'nailing' this song - right now it's tender, all I wanna do is be with it and let it unfold. I don't even think it's a 'nailing' kind of song - like, put it in a box and sum it up. I think that if you do that, you lose what this song is trying to give to you.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Michael for that glorious post. I think your analysis will hold even more true once we see what goes down on Dos---if Oh Love is the contextual bookend to Uno and the cliffhanger for Dos, it would make sense that this song that you're ostensibly saying is about temptation will lead into "It's Fuck Time," and perhaps regret as on "Stray Heart," where we know the lyrics reflect that kind of yearning and regret "Everything that I want/I want from you/but I just can't have you" combined with "I'll never stray again from you."

At the same time, it makes me uncomfortable to overanalyze to such a degree, and place too much explicit meaning on the songs, especially as they pertain to Billie's life. He's mentioned how Redundant, as you said, was kind of about the rut you get into when you're in a long-term relationship (so obviously, he was explicitly referring to his real life situation)... if "Oh Love" is the next step, then maybe he's sharing too much information :P And for that reason, although he's one of the most honest songwriters for whom vanity is never an issue (Case in point, The Grouch: "I don't have sex cause I can't get it up"), I do think it's less specific. That MTV interview that came out today, where he mentions "going crazy" and thinking with your crotch instead of your head, obviously reflects in a less poetic way everything you just explained, and I think you did a better job than Billie of capturing the complexities of that emotion. At the same time, I think even though you've uncovered what's going down in "Oh Love," it likely was written as a somewhat incomplete stream of consciousness that perhaps Billie himself never managed to make total sense of in the way that you did. I think he might benefit from your analysis. Sit him down on a couch and tell him how he really feels :P Nevertheless, if it's possible, you may have dug too deep. As PaulS said, overanalyzed... but I admire it a lot.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ever since Oh Love dropped yesterday, I've been trying to figure out why it seems to resonate with me so much....

I honestly love reading your posts! But this oneblew my mind entirely. I hadn't had the time to sit an analyse the lyrics myself yet, but now I feel I no longer have to. Seriously, one or two of my brain cells might have just orgasmed. :lol:

On an entirely different note (because after Bastard of 1967's posts I don't feel the need to add anything to the discussion of the song :P)....

Wow, what an idea! The song of the week is the single released earlier the same day! :D

Well I thought it ws a pretty obvious choice for song of the week this week. I would of been like "whaaaa? Oh Love is not song of the week?" if they had chosen soemthing else. So don't really get all the comments about this :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting thoughts again, Bastard. You're putting more effort into this than Green Day did ;)

As for the comparison between the straighforward, almost prosaic, style Billie used in the 39/Smooth and Kerplunk days, to his writing on 21stCB and now what little we've seen of Uno, I'd suggest that he's just using a much more stream-of-consciousness and metaphoric style now. If his language were art, it would be more like an impressionist painting or a watercolor than a landscape portrait. It's very artistic, and it's a *lot* harder to "get" because its plain meaning doesn't hit you in the face like his writing did when he was a teenager. Some may say the quality of his songs will suffer because of this, but I feel it elevates them.

I don't think there's anything prosaic about his earlier work (which, for the purposes of this, I'll take to mean from Warning backwards). The sentiments are simple, certainly, but the manner in which they're expressed is at once powerful and heartfelt. Moreover, not only do the lyrics read well, they sing well. Even the more reasonable lines in Oh Love often sound clumsy, as though he's straining for a rhyme. I suppose that is why I have an issue with the notion of this being an impressionist piece of work: he is very clearly working within the traditional boundaries of a pop song, just doing it badly. He isn't breaking into new forms here, rather he has forgetten how to write well.

Your suggestion that this is a stream-of-consciousness song is probably more accurate - one need only listen to Billie talk to realise his strengths lie in reflection, not in spontaneous discussion. We make light of his frequent 'ya know' speech patterns, but songs like this are merely the lyrical form of that. When he sits down and really works through a lyric, I think he can be one of the great mainstream songwriters. When he doesn't - which used to be very rare - we get this and, to a lesser extent, Know Your Enemy.

Again, I don't dispute that he might be trying hard to say something with those two songs, but whatever it is he's not getting there. You make reference to this song having much in common with his lyrics on 21CB, but I've just checked again and almost all of them are perfectly understandable, despite his increased reliance of sloganeering and metaphor. Even the most complex ideas can be made understandable; indeed, it is the mark of a great writer that he or she is able to do so. Billie has done it before - in Jesus of Suburbia, most notably - but this fails to relay even the simplest of messages.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in love with this song. The more I listen to it, the more I relate to it. The lyrics are good, the music is catchy and the solo is just WOW ! The chorus works like a magic in the song. I'm hooked to the chorus. And the falsetto fits in the song too. I'm in love with it. That's it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay, something is really bothering me, so I'm just going to throw it out there.

I'm about 95% convinced that the correct lyrics to the bridge are;

Talk Tug myself out of feeling

Talk Tug my way out of control

Talk Tug myself out of falling in love

Falling in love with you

I know it's kind of arrogant to assume the official (3D!) lyric video is incorrect, but whenever I hear the song I think back to that "laserbeams shooting out of the titties" video where Billie hums a line which I at the time clearly percieved as "tug my way out". I too hear a distinct pronunciation of the word talk/tug in the song, which i guess could be an alternative way of pronouncing talk, but on the other hand a perfect pronunciation of the word tug which is more of a short "tuck" compared to talk which is more like a longer, less sharp "tork". From a poetic standpoint I think this alternative also adds a bit more depth to the bridge and makes the imagery a bit more interesting. (I for example imagine a guy being dragged (tugged) backwards by a rope, arms reaching out, in a sharp pull fashion according to the beat of the music)

When I see the official lyrics posted inside of the iUno! CD-case, I will accept it if I'm proven wrong, but until then I believe it's not impossible that whoever made the youtube video at Warner could have wrote the lyrics out by ear, and the band had nothing to do with that product at all. But what do you think, do you also hear a little ticke-di-tug in there?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay, something is really bothering me, so I'm just going to throw it out there.

I'm about 95% convinced that the correct lyrics to the bridge are;

Talk Tug myself out of feeling

Talk Tug my way out of control

Talk Tug myself out of falling in love

Falling in love with you

I know it's kind of arrogant to assume the official (3D!) lyric video is incorrect, but whenever I hear the song I think back to that "laserbeams shooting out of the titties" video where Billie hums a line which I at the time clearly percieved as "tug my way out". I too hear a distinct pronunciation of the word talk/tug in the song, which i guess could be an alternative way of pronouncing talk, but on the other hand a perfect pronunciation of the word tug which is more of a short "tuck" compared to talk which is more like a longer, less sharp "tork". From a poetic standpoint I think this alternative also adds a bit more depth to the bridge and makes the imagery a bit more interesting. (I for example imagine a guy being dragged (tugged) backwards by a rope, arms reaching out, in a sharp pull fashion according to the beat of the music)

When I see the official lyrics posted inside of the iUno! CD-case, I will accept it if I'm proven wrong, but until then I believe it's not impossible that whoever made the youtube video at Warner could have wrote the lyrics out by ear, and the band had nothing to do with that product at all. But what do you think, do you also hear a little ticke-di-tug in there?

I'm sorry to say this, but you are completely wrong. The word he sings IS actually "Talk". It just sounds to you like "Tug" because that's how most Americans pronounce the word. They don't pronounce it the "British" way as in "Tork".

Also I'm definitely sure the lyrics video has the correct lyrics, since it is the OFFICIAL video put out by the band's youtube account, and probably had access to Billie's actual lyrics written himself, instead of trying to decipher the lyrics by ear like we all have been doing since the Red 7 live recording.

:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here all of you are really digging into the meaning of this song, and all I came here to say is that I love how it teeters on that fine line between being super slow and catchy enough to bounce to.

But then again I suck at analyzing stuff and love songs whose lyrics aren't completely obvious upon the first listen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have much to say about this song... Well, that people haven't already said 20x better than me. So, I will respond with a response deep from my heart. I (oh) love this song.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm very pleased with the sound in Oh Love, though I'm still trying to make up mind up about the lyrics.

This:

Your suggestion that this is a stream-of-consciousness song is probably more accurate - one need only listen to Billie talk to realise his strengths lie in reflection, not in spontaneous discussion. We make light of his frequent 'ya know' speech patterns, but songs like this are merely the lyrical form of that. When he sits down and really works through a lyric, I think he can be one of the great mainstream songwriters. When he doesn't - which used to be very rare - we get this and, to a lesser extent, Know Your Enemy.

...is something I've been thinking about but couldn't quite put to words.

That said, at the moment, I'm leaning more toward being okay with the lyrics - largely because of the way Billie sings the lines. And I expect better things coming from the trilogy, so no worries at all.

(OT I'm always glad to see some love for Billie's 39/Smooth and Kerplunk writing.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm very pleased with the sound in Oh Love, though I'm still trying to make up mind up about the lyrics.

This:

...is something I've been thinking about but couldn't quite put to words.

That said, at the moment, I'm leaning more toward being okay with the lyrics - largely because of the way Billie sings the lines. And I expect better things coming from the trilogy, so no worries at all.

(OT I'm always glad to see some love for Billie's 39/Smooth and Kerplunk writing.)

Exactly.... the music carries the song where the lyrics fail, and we will have TONS of really fascinating, awesome lyrics coming. It'll probably escalate too, with Tre having the most interesting lyrics (99 Revolutions is about Occupy Oakland after all, so it'll probably be like the writing of 21CB). Little Boy Named Train already promises to be fascinating, in my view. I think the lyrics to Amy are beautiful and explicit and symbolic all at once. Considering the music of Oh Love is so beautiful, it's hard to care right now that the lyrics may have fallen short for most of us.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fuck my computer got a virus the day the Green Day tour rumor got out =(. I couldn't listen to the song exactly at 6, but I did get to when the radio played it at 7:10 =). Haha I got up just to listen to Green Day and went back to sleep. Not my favorite Green Day song, but it's good! Can't wait to hear what they have in store for us.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i was pretty mixed when i first heard it but the more i listened to it the more i fell in love with it. such a good song.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have much to say about this song... Well, that people haven't already said 20x better than me. So, I will respond with a response deep from my heart. I (oh) love this song.

Amen to this. :bunny:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.