I get what you're saying, and I agree.

http://groups.msn.com/antijoelmadden/howdi...atredstart.msnw
This site is hilarious. It was made by some teenie who "discovered REAL punk through GC" and fanticised about how she though that she would one day marry him. Then she found out he was dating hilary duff, and realized that joel isn't with her instead, so she made this dumbassed site. True teenie paradise!

that was fucking hilarious

the same band...
I don't listened to it much,but I like their music!
video I JUST WANNA LIVE really funny))

I was just listening to God Save the Queen, and that part sounds exactly like the bridge of The Festival Song. It might just be a tribute to the Pistols though. But either way, they copied 'em.

agree, who cares if they are dating, thats not our business!

I like Good Charlotte. But in my country everybody hete them.

copied them?
oh please.

wow i'm surprised most of the people who voted like them...i didn't realize that many people liked them...i think they're amazing, although you have to be a certin mood to listen to their stuff...i haven't listened to any of their songs in a long time

Compare the last part of God Save The Queen to the bridge of The Festival Song. And last time I checked, the Sex Pistols came first.

Oh yeah, I remember. You're the one that posted "^ probably better then you could ever do." when someone said that GC sucks live (which they do).

It's okay to like GC, but look at the fucking facts. The part in God Save the Queen sounds exactly like the part in The Festival Song.

it still could have been an accident though. counterlife had a song with a riff that sounded just like "dopesick girl" by rancid and the pink spiders have a song that sounds like fucking jennifer lopez i doubt they were trying to rip her off...

Good point. But still, I think they were fans of the Pistols. But whatever. I still like both songs.

which pink spiders song sounds like j-lo?

"lovers into ghosts". just the beat that they sing the chorus in. at least me, my brother, and my boyfriend thought it had a really similar rhythm.

There are some GC CDs for like 1 cent on amazon. I'll buy the first 2 albums soon.

i just bought "the young and the hopeless" for $4.99 today

I just listened to it, and it does! Hah, that's great.

i like there older stuff like the anthem and lifestyles of the rich and famous but there lastest album was really shit and boring

i'll listen to them, but they're not one of my favorite bands.

i say beggers cant be choosers. being from maryland, their name is known all over the world. that alone is impressive. even if you dont like there music, you know their name. me, i like there old stuff better than there new stuff but i thought the video for Predictible was really cool. they even helped us get HFS back when it was taken off the air. whether or not i like the music, i hav no choice but to respect them as people. its a maryland thing. i guess.

i'm glad to see that someone else can respect them despite the fact that "omg! they're not punk!!!" thumbs up to you

i like some of their songs.
which i sing every day becuase they are somekind sticky (i don't know how to say that, sorry )

i think you mean that it's catchy

i think so hahah
thanks ^^

They have some good songs, they have some not so good songs, but over all they have pretty cool songs!

I hate the way they dress all "punk style" and act all hardxcore, and the music is anything but punk, they suck.

so... if you were into emo music and dressed like an emo kid and you had a metalhead friend ask you to join their metal band and accepted, you would have to change the way you dress and act?

i dont hate them or anything, just that i dont see much talent in them but i do listen to some of their songs sometimes

^ that billy martin fellow isn't actually that bad of a guitarist. no mueseroso or anything, but he's pretty good.

If I was into emo music I wouldn't join a metal band in the first place, since that's not the kind of music I'm into.
But what I don't understand is what does this have to do with Good Charlotte?

I don't like them I think because Joel Madden loves stupid Hilary Duff! Plus they kinda changed!

But he ended this relationship, so it's okay now Everybody make mistakes.

they can't be into punk music and play other kinds of music?

and some people just like to play or like more than one kind of music, so though emo may be their music of choice, they could still be into metal and like to play a lot so they decide to join a metal band with some friends.

hate them, it's pathetic, when they say that they're punk.

yeah, cause punk is some big honor that only certain people can claim to be, right?

Damn, I just got Punk'd Pwn'd

that's fucking stupid. you don't hate a band because of their personal love interest.

plus, unfortunately they broke up. which sucks because i loved them together.

gc broke up? I thought they were making a new album.

no, i think they mean that joel and hillary duff broke up. you're right, GC is making another album at the moment

Yeah. But I get her point Hillary Duff makes me wanna trow up.

I used to like Good Charlotte a lot. But now I'm starting to listen to other bands and I don't like them as much.

no. they say that they're punk, then they're in every fucking teen magazine, and they turn to pop (yeah they never played punk). they'd be still ok, if they hadn't never said that they're punk. i don't say i'd listen them, but they could be ok. now they're just pathetic little something

I can't stand them at all as people, they're just plain weird AND mighty depressive!
Slightly scary at times
BUT
I must say that quite a few songs on their 1st and 2nd albums are really catchy.
Anthem is the best song they ever did and I don't think they can top it. thats why they suck so much now.
I just wanna live takes the piss and thats why i love that song still...

i think you people look way too far into things that dont even matter and forget what's important about bands in the first place: their music.

ohh yeah
just watched it on tv
joel and hillary duff broke up
omg is that terrible

So does anyone know when their new album comes out?
I really want to listen to some new material from them!

Eh. Check their website?

Omg. I think they have a new album!

I used to Love them on there 1st and 2nd album
but after those 2 i thort they got worse

and there new song GET UR HANDS OFF MY GIRL
is soooo BAD!!

Yes, that song is kinda dodgy Hope the rest of their album is better.

Sometime in march I think the 4th or somewhere around there.